Not an expert on keeper leagues, but here is my critique. First 8 selections were unbelievable, not just that you got them on your team, but that you got some guys so late. Berkman @59, Holliday @86, Webb @83, Beltran @38, even Utley @14 all perplexed me, but once again, I have never done a keeper draft, and am not quite sure if its a good strategy to leave very talented players on the board. Oh well, all the more for your benefit. Not sure what all of your 12 categories are, but I will rate you at the normal 10 categories I am accustommed to. Batting average w/ Utley, Jeter, Berkman, & Holliday you should be good, but w/ Beltran, Beltre, & Willingham you won't be great. Hr's & RBI's you might struggle a bit. The only real HR & RBI studs I see are Beltran & Berkman. The rest are good, but not great. Runs should be phenomenal, no problems there. SB's should be hit or miss from week to week. Overall hitting looks good, but your later picks are a bit on the weak side. Pitching looks good also. Wins should be pretty good. Santana, Schmidt, Webb, & Bonderman is a very, very, very solid 4. All 4 guys can do it all. Wins, low era, low whip, and good so's. Good job w/ that. Also love Papelbon, and the fact ya got him so late in the draft is even better. Your bullpen is horrible. Sorry, just being honest. Valverde is average at best, Linebrink is a question mark to ever close, simply b/c he never has done it, like Fuentes, but he won't get ya alot of saves and Madson is too inconsistent for me.
Overall, your team is very solid, but has a few holes. If you show up your bullpen, and get one more big bopper via the trade, ya got a perfect team. Overall, I give your team a 8 outta 10.
Please rate mine...
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/foru ... p?t=245219