DK wrote:agreed. ichiro got it, matsui should at least be eligible. he should win it as well, IMO.
I guess. However, Berroa's numbers are very, very good, too. So I look at it like MVP. I'd like to give the award to a team that made or nearly made the playoffs, though I don't think it's necessary.
Arod wins by default, this year, then.
So I'll only give it to "fake" rookies when there are no other deserving canidates. Hence Berroa.