Since you have a relief pitcher listed and you haven't given much information about your roster, this is a pretty tough question to answer.
That said, these kinds of questions are very time-consuming to answer (like rate my team and trade questions). And given that I only like putting good advise on the table, I think I'm going to cut down to one a day.
Maybe Arlo would be interested in having a weekly article on keeper decisions. I could do something three detailed questions a week.
If he'll post my responses and you give me more background on your team, I'll consider making this part of my first article.
Mike Pelfrey > Matt Garza