vladrules wrote:He better be! I traded Dunn and Otsuka for him.
thats not a good trade in my mind even with how well peavy has played. Otsuka is a solid closer with Dunn being a good power source minus average...
I traded jered weaver and freddy sanchez for peavy.....I think thats fair value on either side
Don't know that it's not a "good trade," and that minus average is a BIG minus, I'd rather have the top 5 pitcher, especially if I need pitching. Depends on team needs big time.
Also, never been high on Rob Deer, errr Dunn, i'd rather have a player that can hit 30-33 or so homers and a .290-.300 average than one that can hit 40-43 with a .250 average an 170-190 whiffs. Well especially a league that deducts for whiffs, but he'll nail you in the average category in a h2h league.
But definately not a "bad" trade.