SirDunkALot wrote:Heh, didn't know my post could create so much controversy.
I think this keeper league will be going on for at least probably 5 years. All of our members are active and are hardcore baseball addicts.
But, Top 5 - 10 seems to be maybe the consensus. At least a first rounder.
Are we thinking like:
Perhaps even Beltran?
ahead of MCab? Or where would I sandwich him?
I would be a bit hesitant on Ortiz because of his body type (fat slob/Mo Vaughn type) and age. I might be inclined in a keeper to go with someone like MCab first.
Hafner is not position elig, so I would definitely rather have MCab for 3b. Nothing wrong with Hafner, but DH is not where I would be starting if given the choice.
Beltran...I just do not trust him after 05. He can be a top round 1 player for sure, but I just do not have the rock-solid confidence in him to pick him over MCab. Calll me crazy, but I do not like risk in the early rounds.
I would add Santana onto the list. You could also make very strong cases for Howard and Utley, but probably not quite yet.
Last edited by TheYanks04 on Tue Aug 01, 2006 1:07 am, edited 1 time in total.