I don't think he peak was high enough. Only 2 top 10 finishes in OBP and only 5 top 10 finishes in SLG. Like I said 84-87 he was great but that is only 4 years and while his OPS+ during those years are really good they aren't great for a 1B.noseeum wrote:He had an amazing six year run. Whoever said his peak was not high enough, WHAT? His peak is certainly high enough. His 1985 year is amazing. Don't compare it to stats now. Compare it to stats then. Top 10 in pretty much every offensive category, and number 1 in many of them. Plus, the gold glove.