davidmarver wrote:Bagwell is the easiest of those presented thus far.
33rd on the All-Time OPS+ list, he's created the 31st most runs in baseball history, all while playing very good defense (+122 FRAA) in a low-scoring park.
The Bagwell/McGriff comparison is pretty poor. To supplement the OPS+ and RC numbers, Bagwell has a WARP3 (Wins Above Replacement Player) of 135, while McGriff is only 102 WARP3 in his career.
I say he's in fairly easily...certainly easier than Kent, Biggio, or Glavine.
You read my mind. Imo, Bagwell should be a lock.