Points all the way. I am in a roto league and a points league. I think head to head points is more exciting and fun. While roto is kind of boring. Points are especially fun b/c it is more than just 5 catergories by 5 catergories. In my points league things like pick offs, caught stealing, loses, complete games, shut outs, doubles, triples, and hitting for the cycle all count for positive or negative points. While there may be more luck involved in head to head it is much more entertaining but it remains challenging.