I would say about 6/10. Pudge is great as a catcher, nevin is slow performing even since his injury, castillo is decent. Blalock is hitting for average pretty well and is on a good lineup for hitting. Arod is of course a rod and your ofs are pretty good. Work on your pitching tho. Guardado is decent and prior is amazing but buehrle has been good lately after a horrific start. Maddux just isnt maddux so make some trades then you will have a chance.
Hey. Awesome Site.
Anyway, your team is a little weak on pitching, as John said. Ibanez? Keep him benched unless someone gets hurt... Milton Bradley's actually doing fairly well, last time I checked. A-rod at SS Nevin at IB is great. Pudge is also a good addition. THe outfield is OK, but Manny is the strong point. You will get frusterated at his lazyness on the field - believe me. Castio is mediocre. I dont know much about Blalock, as the only two teams I cover avidly are the Red Sox and the Yankees (BOO).
Your team isn't actually that bad, but it needs more hitting. 7.5/10.
You're pitching isn't as bad as everyone says. Prior, Beckett, Buehrle and Maddux (when he's not pitching against he Phills) is a nice quad in the rotation. You really need to upgrade @ 1B and 2B. Nevin doesn't have the power to be anyones everyday 1B this year. Pick up Josh Phelps if you can. He should close out the year strong.