Alright, I'll be the first one here to admit that I reached for him. I took him in round 7 in a 12 team league.
He was the 13th 1B taken. It was sort of a panic move b/c I just wanted to fill my 1B spot already as the choices were thinning out. I had him ranked about 8th or 9th on my 1B cheatsheet. I announced it was a reach when I selected him but I still caught crap for it. Leaguewide it was deemed as the worst pick of the draft. Needless to say I am the one laughing now.