Fair enough, but I wasn't the one who turned this into a Jeter being overrated thread. That being said, I did mention that I would rather have Renteria, because of the stolen bases, and because that lineup has been on fire all season. I will say, that the poll is a fair one, because I think most will give Jeter too little credit in terms of what he can do, and he will be much easier to trade for now than Edgar, and may well have similar production.
BTW, sometimes the topics in threads evolve from one subject to another very closely related subject. Talking about why Jeter is or isn't overrated is pretty relevant to the subject at hand. I'd rather pick on someone for not substantiating points like "Jeter is overrated" than for straying (not far mind you) from topic.