reyes, crawford, ordonez, buehrle
tejada, pierre, sheff, and schilling
Manny's about the same as Guerero, and Millwood is crap. So your basically giving:
Reyes, Crawford, Ordonez, and Buehrle
Tejada, Pierre, Sheff, and Schilling
Looks like a great deal to me
as for the other trade...
Felix + Crawford + B.J. Ryan
Carpenter + Hafner + Sizemore
I think this is a very even but i wouldn't take it if i were you because you only have 3 closers and losing one would be a big blow to your saves.
Suggestion: Go pick up Papelbon on the Sox then maybe you can trade BJ