The consensus 'safe' pick might be Overbay, but I like Shelton and D. Johnson over Overbay and Jacobs, so flip a coin between Shelton and D. Johnson. Do holds count in your league? If not, maybe you can drop either Linebrink (or Silva if holds does count) and pick up Heilman.
C-BMolina 1B-Votto 2B-Utley 3B-Youk SS-Furcal LF-JDamon CF-BJUpton
RF-ARios UT-DLee BN-Scutaro,CBlake,Schumaker DL-JReyes
SP-SBaker RP-ABailey P-Saito,Hawkins,JJohnson,Dempster,Danks,JShields,Garza