Giants Rule wrote: I like the weekly drama and results right away so we know where we stand. I also like the weekly trash talking, taunting and trade talks
That pretty much sums up H2H IMO, short term satisfaction. What I don't like about H2H is if you 'bend the rules', you can give yourself a big edge. With no inning limits, people use mass pitching to beat you. Stocking up on 2 start pitchers is another way to manipulate the results.
You can draft all offense, and just outnumber your opponent with lame pitchers and crush the league. The Rangers have proven that isn't the way it works in baseball.
I like H2H in football, because every team plays once a week, and the season is fairly short. You can't use 9 different QB's and beat your opponent. It's the best of your roster vs the best of his. Roto football sucks.
Roto baseball rules. I'd put a total point league after that, with H2H a distant 3rd.