Unless key defensive statistics are in your league (PBs, Es, Baserunners thrown out, etc.) then don't even consider Matheny.
You can expect some offense out of Marrero and Pierzynski. 2nd tier would be Larue. Then Olivio. 4th tier is Martinez, Hundley, and Molina. Bottom tier is Matheny.
Tom in the 847
Does your league need a quality, outside review of your league rulebook? Does your league not have a written rulebook? Contact me! I can help.