I totally disagree. The thing that makes him the most valuable in real baseball are the walks he takes. But who cares about this in 5x5?
The reality his that he is a zero cat fantasy player. Sure his BA is OK, but he has very little power and provides very little in terms of SBs. In 808 career ABs he has 6 SB and 21 HRs.
Compounding this is the fact that he is moving from a strong hitters park to a poor hitters park and that his career stats are distorted ina way that is favorable to him due to a disporportionate amount of ABs against lefties. And oh yeah he is 30 years old and wil lnot be getting any better.
Over a full season in Cleveland he might deliver something like .280/10/3. This would not even excite people if he were a 2B, but an OF with those stats is utterly from a fantasy perspective.
Like I said, it is a idfferent equation for real MLB, where he does have some clear value to the Indians.