This really is difficult to read. And I don;t think anyone will agree with you 100%.
I think there are a lot of problems. Willis too high, Carpenter a tad high, Schilling high, pettitte high, Burnett high, prior low, and then I really have major problems in you rmiddle grouping. I'm not even sure where to start. Bedard and lackey over HArden? Escobar over Garland? Lieber over Hudson? Chacon over Sabathia/Morris/Perez/etc.? I have less problems at the end, as they are so interchangeable. I think you really need to re-look at the middle grouping.