Best SP for rest of '05?

[bigh0rt]

R. Tejeda
Od. Perez
E. Santana
R. Rodriguez
J. Blanton
Ru. Hernandez
S. Elarton

So? Feel free to rank them if you want, or just say who's the clear cut #1, why, whatever.

[J35J]

Odalis Perez

[Members Only Jackets]

Odalis Perez

I agree...he's the clear cut #1 IMO

E Santana is the sleeper from the bunch.

[G-Man]

odalis without question.

[TheYanks04]

Like there is a point to this question with Odalis Perez being about 10 miles in front of the rest of that WW or near WW trash?

[baseballnewb]

Perez is the best of that bunch though I personally doubt he'll stay healthy. The rest of those guys, well I feel bad if you have to start one of them full time.

[bigh0rt]

Like there is a point to this question with Odalis Perez being about 10 miles in front of the rest of that WW or near WW trash?

Your arrogance is a pretty big turnoff, and not only in this thread. The question was not asked in order for me to figure out what to do with my team. I've got Odalis on roster. I was debating with a fellow owner who wondered why I'd keep Perez on my roster for the past few weeks and not getting production out of him, mentioning the other pitchers in my original thread as viable options I should've considered, with my other pitchers having struggled the past two weeks. I argued that over the long term, Perez is a much wiser investment for me. I figured I'd post it up here to see if people agreed with me. Apparently they do. You'd be wise to drop your holier than thou attitude though. It's growing tired.

So, there's the point to the question. You're welcome.

[TheYanks04]

Well maybe if you took the time to enlighten us with your rational you would not come across as asking a question meriting a mocking response.

[bigh0rt]

Well maybe if you took the time to enlighten us with your rational you would not come across as asking a question meriting a mocking response.

Touche. Next time I'll be certain to be more specific.

I'm not perfect but 'choose one' has to be about prospects or something with more meat than waiver stuff or trades.

Half a dozen threads of this nature are posted in this forum, responded to heavily, and not killed by the hampster, every single day. Because you consider a question of the nature to warrant a question regarding prospects or something "with more meat" doesn't make it the be all end all, or necessarily even place you in the majority. I don't feel it belongs in the Analyze/Rate forum, nor the Draft/Trade forum, nor any of the other specified forums. Hence, Baseball Leftovers. That's just my train of thought, though.

Though I'm certain there wouldn't have been such controversy had I been more specific. Live and learn.