An Iconic Fantasy Baseball Community
Moderator: Baseball Moderators
ocmusicjunkie wrote:davidmarver wrote:Peavy's a top 6 pitcher in all the major leagues, let alone "youth".
Randy, Santana, Prior, Oswalt, Hudson, Sheets, Harden all get votes ahead of him in my book. Schmidt and Pedro would in most people's books.
Of course, that is all injury-pending... but I remember Peavy missing some time last year too.
WittyC wrote:Also, rating Peavy anywhere near Carlos Zambrano is just a joke. They're essentially the same style of pitcher (high BB, high K), except Zamby's done it successfully for 2 full seasons, whereas Peavy did it for 166 innings in the one of the best pitchers' park in the league.
Let Peavy put together a full season that even sniffs what Zamby's done and I think we can start to give him some credit. Until then I just can't place him in that "top-tier" of pitchers.
ocmusicjunkie wrote:BTW... I'm 100% sure that order does mean something. They even said for #20 "Kazmir could have taken this spot". Obviously meaning Francis was #20.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests