No one seem to be taking the upside of Bay. I like Giles, but he has topped out. We arent going to see 30 HRs, 100RBIS from Giles again. I like him for more guartanteed production (23+HRs, 82+RBIS,etc) but Bay has MUCH greater upside. If Giles/Bay is your #2 OF then take Giles. If its Giles/Bay for #3 or UT take Bay because he could push you well beyond Giles expectations. I know the guy is starting slow, but hte posibilites are there.