This is strictly my opinion, but there is no way i take a RP in the second round, especially if my first pick was a SP. And under no circumstances would i take 3 closers in the first 6 rounds.
I think taking Pudge in the 3rd may have been a little bit of a reach, and given that he was your first offensive player, you should have ignored positions and taken the best hitter available.
Your team has a glaring need for a stud offensive player ANYWHERE. You don't have that reliable early round guy that you know will put up numbers. There really is no need to have three elite closers on your roster, so i would definatly try to move one for a bat.