Furcal or Rollins?? Who would you rather have??

[Guttenburg]

I'd be trading Josh Beckett straight up for 1 of these 2 shortstops.

[thehat]

Rollins. And I would definitely make that deal.

[so0perspam]

Very close, but I'm expecting a huge year out of Furcal.

[bruuno2]

I think Beckett is worth more than either one of those jokers.However if i must i'd choose Furcal.

[FatGuyWithAMullet]

Furcal, Rollins is so overrated right now it's ridiculous.

[CubsFan7724]

Furcal. Rollins is vastly overrated.

[Melo255]

hmm I expected to be the only one to be saying Furcal but I guess that all the Rollins hype is finally starting to die down. Furcal!

[Broncmet724]

Furcal

[Armed and Hammered]

Their numbers last year and projected numbers this year are about the same. I don't see either of them tailing off. Almost too close to call. Furcal seems a bit more injury prone. Rollins has missed only 26 games in 4 years. I'd lean Rollins. Think he has a higher ceiling and plays in a better park. Very similar though.

[Guttenburg]

I think I like Furcal better but his injury history makes me wanna go with Rollins instead.

My team(16 team H2H, btw)is listed below.

C-Brandon Inge
1BMark Texeria
2B-Todd Walker
SS-Omar Infante
3B-David Wright
OF-Bobby Abreu
OF-Carl Crawford
OF-Craig Monroe
Uti-Brad Wilkerson
Bench- T. Iguchi

SP-Mark Buerhle
SP-Jake Peavy
SP-Josh Beckett
SP-Jeremy Bonderman
SP-Zach Greinke
RP-Ugeth Urbina
RP-Brad Lidge
RP-Jeremy Affeldt
RP-Mike Adams

I figure I can sacrafice an arm for some middle infield depth..which I think I kind of desperatly need.