Here is what Chone, Marcel, and Bill James average out to (assuming a career average # of AB for both - excluding rookie years and prior)
Crawford: 588AB, 91R, 13HR, 75RBI, 40SB, .295 avg
Bay: 571AB, 96R, 27HR, 96RBI, 9SB, .272 avg
Both estimates are fairly conservative in my mind.
So which is worth more to you?
30 SB and 20 points of AVG?
15 HR and 20 RBI?
I don't think it is too much of a close call. I'll take Crawford all day here.