If Gary Sheffield retired today would he be a first ballot Hall Of Famer?

newer poll	Cafe Poll If Gary Sheffield retired today would he be a first ballot Hall Of Famer? No, never won an MVP, he needs to reach 500 HR to be strongly considered.  77.8% Yes, 481 career HR, 9 time All Star, he should make Cooperstown easily.  22.2% Total votes: 81	older poll
	Overview