| Who should be the AL's starting pitcher in the All-Star Game? |
| Dan Haren (10-2, 98 K, 2.20 ERA) |
 | 40.0% |
|
| Johan Santana (10-6, 125 K, 2.75 ERA) |
 | 21.9% |
|
| C.C. Sabathia (12-2, 119 K, 3.58 ERA) |
 | 14.3% |
|
| Josh Beckett (12-2, 92 K, 3.44 ERA) |
 | 11.4% |
|
| Justin Verlander (103, 97 K, 3.14 ERA) |
 | 7.6% |
|
| John Lackey (11-5, 87 K, 3.04 ERA) |
 | 2.9% |
|
| Gil Meche (5-6, 84 K, 3.26 ERA) |
 | 1.9% |
|
Total votes: 105
|
|
|