Reyes and Nomar a Risk?

[go_jays_go]

What do you guys think of Jose Reyes? and Nomar Garciaparra? Are they still vaulable or should I get rid of them selling them high?

[go_jays_go]

Anyone please help! I need it quickly! I'll help you! Thanks

[go_jays_go]

PLEASE HELP

[SaintsOfTheDiamond]

Depends on what you could get for them. I really like Nomar in '05 (have him as my No. 2/3 SS going in) and Reyes has all the potential in the world, but I don't think you could get enough in return right now to justify dealing him at this point. So, I'd probably hang on to both since their values are relatively low and you wouldn't get good value in return.

[Jivedude]

Depends on what you could get for them. I really like Nomar in '05 (have him as my No. 2/3 SS going in) and Reyes has all the potential in the world, but I don't think you could get enough in return right now to justify dealing him at this point. So, I'd probably hang on to both since their values are relatively low and you wouldn't get good value in return.

Yeah I certainly wouldn't use the phrase "selling high" in regards to those two.

[xtrm84]

are they still valuable?!?!?! Reyes has got to be the most upcoming SS in the league, and nomar......that guy had one bad season and now hes back, you watch. Can I hear MVP?

[nikku88]

They are definitely risky because of their past injuries, but I don't see a reason to trade them unless the offer blows you away as they have the ability to be very, very good.

[Apollo]

At this point, with their respective injuries, neither of them have as much value as they could. If you have both, I'd give Reyes a couple weeks into the season, let him steal five bases, and deal him before his leg pops again. But right now you won't get amazing value for either.