Beckett, or Halladay?

[RynMan]

Yeah, I just dont think I would feel comfortable with Beckett on my team yet. He will always go much higher than I am willing to take him (due to the potential upside that people may get), and as a result he will never be on my team.

[bleach168]

Halladay
Beckett



Mulder


Halladay only gets a slight edge over Beckett. If I can get Beckett a round or two later, that's would be awesome. Someday Beckett will overcome his blister problems but that may not be this year. In a keeper league, I would have Beckett rated much higher than the other two.

[Bloody Nipples]

In a keeper league, I would have Beckett rated much higher than the other two.

I'm not sure why. Halladay is young as well. He's only 27 or 28.

I have them like this:

Halladay

Beckett



Mulder

[GoatLocker]

Halladay
Mulder


Beckett

Close between Halladay and Mulder.
Then see a drop off to Beckett.

[bleach168]

In a keeper league, I would have Beckett rated much higher than the other two.

I'm not sure why. Halladay is young as well. He's only 27 or 28.

I have them like this:

Halladay

Beckett



Mulder

This isn't an age issue. This is a "nasty stuff" issue. Beckett's will be able to match Halladay in every category except K's where Beckett will really shine over Halladay.

[CubsFan7724]

I like it in the safest order:
Halladay
Beckett
Mulder

Mulders slides scare me, and I feel Halladay is going to bounce back nicely. Beckett has chronic blister problems, I'm guessing similar to the ones that plagued Affeldt and Matt Mantei. Though I think Affeldt fixed it by having his fingernails removed.

[curious_george_43545]

If it helps I drafted Halladay 7th in my last draft and didnt draft either or the other 2