Cafe Awards

[Arlo]

As always, we welcome your comments on the latest article. Time for the Soriano, A-Rod, Schilling and Pedro owners to stand up for their guys!

[mcfbc]

With no offense to the greatness of Guerrero, Soriano, Johnson and Schilling, I have to throw my vote behind A-Rod. Behind the numbers (which were spectactular for all these players) comes the reality of the positions they play. At a position that is void of quality and depth, what A-Rod is doing is unheard of in the history of baseball (real or fantasy). A-Rod is the best player in the game (both real and fantasy) and will remain so for years to come. Having said all that, I would take any of the aformentioned players in a heartbeat. Guerrero, Soriano, A-Rod. So young. Lord only knows what their numbers will look like ten years from now. Peace. Go Rangers (2010 World Series Champs)!!!

[Arlo]

Agreed - if we had factored in positional scarcity, A-Rod and Soriano would both have been ahead of Vlad. We went by total stats, but with A-Rod's stats from the ss position, you could easily make the call in his favor.

Tough year to choose, as there was nobody who was head and shoulders above the rest...