Which set of keepers do you like better?

[chadbenedict]

H2H 12 Team

Pitchers get 10 for Saves/Wins; 2 Pts Inning; 1pt K; -.5 for Hit/BB; -1 for ER.

My team: Soriano/Cabrera/Manny/Schmidt/Prior I have 1st round picks #4,#7,#9,#10,#11.

04' Winner: Tejada/Vladi/Pujols/Peavy/Gagne He has 1st round pick #1 and 2nd round pick #15.

[so0perspam]

I really like Gagne in this scoring system, especially with 10 points per save and -1 for ER .... I'd take the '04 winner.

[Bobblehead]

I like the 04 winner's keepers better.

[mrtsc]

Definately 04 Winner's.

[jonessoda1314]

do you have to have a starter? or can you have 2 RPs? becuase with saves beign 10 along with wins, a mediocre closer can get 20 saves pretty easily

[kljsoccer18]

the '04 winner's keepers are better but seeing that you basically own the first round and that he has only the first pick overall, i think you should be able to have a better team than him this year if you choose wisely

[Egregious]

I agree with both klj and jonessoda: his keepers are better, but you ought to be able to come out ahead after the draft, and given your scoring system, you might want to think about keeping a closer, as long as his job is safe (sounds odd to suggest keeping an average closer over Schmidt or Prior, but your scoring system is odd). Actually, though, with the ks good SPs should come out ahead, so maybe it's not so odd.

[Pogotheostrich]

04 winner. Depending on who is kept you could end up with the better team but he has some awesome keepers and that is the team I would want.