Im going with Mr. Dallas on this one. I dont like how injury prone Glaus is. But really, what you are doing here is deciding which of the two players will play to their true potential. this is a risky thing to do on both sides. I would try for someone consistant, so you know what you are getting. You want McPherson to play like he did in the minors, and you want Galus to play the way he did when he was healthy.
"I live for this game. If baseballs went well with eggs, Id eat them for breakfast..."