3 HUGE DEALS...Which one would you pick?

[AI8818]

I need quick help so I would like to know which of these trades you would do, or would be best for my team?!

1
I GET: Torii Hunter
I GIVE: Luis Gonzo, Griffey,Wickman

2
I GET: Vernon Wells
I GIVE: Keith Foulke

3
I GET: Soriano, Michael Young, Aaron Boone
I GIVE: Nomar, Blalock, Halladay, Foulke

THANKS!!

12 Team, 5x5, H2h

C Ivan Rodriguez
1B Derrek Lee
2B Jeff Kent
SS Nomar Garciaparra
3B Hank Blalock
OF Vladimir Guerrero
OF Coco Crisp
OF Luis Gonzalez
Util Troy Glaus
BN Ken Griffey Jr.
BN Richard Hidalgo
BN Juan Uribe
BN Chris Burke

SP Roy Halladay
SP Barry Zito
SP C.C. Sabathia
RP Eddie Guardado
RP Keith Foulke
P Mark Buerhle
P Bob Wickman
P Tom Gordon
BN Adam Eaton

[Kingctb27]

I really don't like any of these deals, but If i did one I would probably do the 2nd one. Your Of is kinda weak.

[foulballstrike3]

Well, you definitely shouldn't do deal #3. I don't like where it puts you for saves if you do #2. #1 isn't bad, but Gonzo or Griffey, if either is healthy, are worth just as much as Hunter. Don't do any of them.

[foulballstrike3]

Sorry, me again, just out of curiousity, why would you have even considered deal #3? You are giving up a ton for speed basically. Soriano isn't nearly the runner he was now that he's w/ texas. You already have Vlad, Lee and Crisp for SBs. These are huge deals, but huge deals for the other party.

[AI8818]

Lol, sorry. I shouldnt have posted #3...My fault, my fault.

[tlef316]

this is the wrong forum for this. please post your trade questions in the correct place.

[Mills13]

um, they are all bad.