manny ramirez vs bobby abreu

[tuff_gong]

which one of these late 1st round outfielders would you rather have and why? i myself would choose abreu cause i love 5 category guys.

[so0perspam]

I'd probably rather have Manny because of the HR, RBI, and BA advantages, but the better option here would be to wait until the 2nd round to nab Abreu if you know he'll be there.

[Kingctb27]

I would probably go with Manny because he is in a better line-up...Although im a little biased.

[fantasyfiend]

I like Abreu (by a strong margine) over Manny. He gives me more flexibility the rest of the way considering he contributes majorly in all 5 categories.

[ayebatter]

I'd probably rather have Manny because of the HR, RBI, and BA advantages, but the better option here would be to wait until the 2nd round to nab Abreu if you know he'll be there.

if Abrue falls to the second you could end up with both - take Manny

[fantasyfiend]

If Abreu falls to the 2nd your in a league full of morons and it would be no satisfaction to win your league.

[Amazinz]

I'd take Manny. I have him ranked as a mid-1st rounder and Abreu late 1st, early 2nd.

[fantasyfiend]

So what are your projections for Manny and Abreu (out of curiosity)

[Amazinz]

Manny BA .310+ R 110+ HR 40+ RBI 120+ SB 0-
Abreu BA .300+ R 100+ HR 25+ RBI 100- SB 30+

[jonessoda1314]

If Abreu falls to the 2nd your in a league full of morons and it would be no satisfaction to win your league.

abreu goes in the 1st round in almost every league ive beenin/seen
hells hit .300 105 rbi, 110 runs, 30 homers, 35 SB.... i love abreu very consistant, no injuries