Wickman or Dempster? Who's the better closer?

[AI8818]

Whiich of these closers will perform the best in 2005. The league Im in is a 5x5, H2H (if it helps). Which of them will all-around have a solid season without a chance of them losing the job. THANKS!

[AI8818]

Can anyone please help me out here?

[so0perspam]

Wickman .... it's not even close in my mind.

[Nat Uralice]

Wickman by a long shot at least now. Dempster has no prior closing experience, which Wickman has plenty of. Dempster might be able to shine there but it's a risky pick. Also, his leash is shorter (could be a committe sooner than later).

[Surfs up]

I agree

[Rico The Retard]

Wickman, Dempster isnt even a sure thing to get saves this year

[kimchi_chigae]

i think you meant to ask...who will perform this year, right?

wickman is definitely the way to go. dempster is too big of a question mark. on the other hand he's canadian and we all saw what they can do when moved from the starting rotation to the closer role...

seriously. take wickman. the tribe has a good ofense, in a weak division and their bullpen, which was a major problem last year, has got a lot better.