I believe Dans misunderstood you, even though your thread is quite confusing. He thought you got 2 players against Arod, whereas I believe you're saying, whoever wins in 2 of the catz wins the bet. What happens if there is an injury? I'm guessing you're cancelling it? Anyways, I think Manny could do it, but his RBIs just jumped back up again last year after two seasons right around 100, but his avg. dove considerably after striking out a bunch more. Arods HRs dropped last year, but they should jump back up I would GUESS. Anyways, I wouldn't be comfortable taking Manny. As far as Vlad goes, he should easily beat Arod in Avg., but you just never know w/ HRs and RBIs. He outperformed Arod in both, but I just see Arods #s coming back up. It has to be one of those 2, but it is anything from a sure bet. If you like to gamble, do it now, but I'm guessing he won't let you take Pujols, haha. Personally, I would take Vlad, but Manny is right there too.