Who to take (Keeper)

[brandnew]

Hey guys, looking for a little advice. I have a couple picks coming up back to back, one guy ahead of me. We keep 8, 5x5 roto, my team so far is M-Cab, Prior, David Wright, Lidge, K-Rod. I know one guy I'm getting with one of these picks, who should I take with the other? (I can't say who I'm taking, since it's a cafe league, same one as Mmoney, MeShawn, Flockers, etc.) thanks for the help

Edmonds
Mulder
Burnett
Furcal
Loretta
Kent

I'm leaning towards either Mulder or Edmonds... what do you think?

[El Jefe]

Of those listed, I'd take Edmonds.

[Irish]

Of those listed, I'd take Edmonds.

Yeah, you need some bats quick, before they disappear.

[brandnew]

Alright, well I'm up. I'm going to take Mauer, and I'm still undecided on the list of those guys. Renteria can be scratched off that list, he was taken. Should I get Mulder, and then get another bat in the 7th? (I can't keep my 8th, as I traded my 9th & 11th for Wright & 18th) Or, should I get Edmonds, and reap his offense for the next 4 years, and try to grab a second tier SP next round?

[wrveres]

edmonds

[giants8307]

Edmonds. Your staff looks great with 2 outstanding closers + prior.

[brandnew]

OK, so my roster right now is:

C. Mauer
3B. Wright
OF. M-Cab
OF. Edmonds

SP. Prior
RP. Lidge
RP. K-Rod

I have two picks coming up, I wanna take a SP, these are the ones left:

Javy Vazquez
Penny
Clement
Colon
Livan Hernandez

What SP should I take?

And with my second pick, it doesn't have to be a keeper, so any ideas as to who I should get? I'm thinking of taking Reyes, to get some SB, and maybe he'll contend with Edmonds for a keeper spot. Or, I could go with these guys as keepers, and grab an older SP.

[WhosBabeRuth]

Javy Vazquez - no run support in Arizona, will he bounce back mentally?
Penny - Injury Risk
Clement - Switching Leagues, can he finally put it together?
Colon - Great Pitcher, great 2nd half
Livan Hernandez - Inning eater, no run support

My Vote goes to Bartolo and then my debate was between Clement and Livan, but putting me being a sox fan aside, i'll say Bartolo and Livan are your best bets. Although keep in mind how many innings Livan throws, he could start to break down this, or in a few years. If your afraid of that, go for Clement.

Josh

[GoatLocker]

My Vote goes to Bartolo and then my debate was between Clement and Livan, but putting me being a sox fan aside, i'll say Bartolo and Livan are your best bets. Although keep in mind how many innings Livan throws, he could start to break down this, or in a few years. If your afraid of that, go for Clement.

Josh

Couldn't have said it better

[WhosBabeRuth]

Couldn't have said it better

Thats because im a genius