Lidge or K-Rod?

[brandnew]

Who do you like better? Both post sick K numbers, K-Rod is younger, plays for a much better team, with good offense, mediocre pitching (Save opps), Lidge is proven, little older, and plays for mediocre offense, still good pitching (Clemens, Oswalt, Pettitte). So, who would you take?

[Mustangs989]

I have Lidge slightly ahead of KRod

[Yoda]

I think Krod will be better at the end of the season (just a hunch) but Lidge should command more value right now.

[free]

lidge....just based on him making the cards look stupid silly in the playoffs last year seriously, i dont think you could go wrong with either. i believe lidge does have an extensive injury history though someone can correct me here if i'm wrong.

[kentx12]

Both have nasty stuff but I have Lidge a little higher.

[BigBobE]

I have to Lidge the nod based on experience.

[GSes]

LIDGE by a mile. he is the MAN

[Tavish]

I have K-Rod rated pretty high, but not all that close to Lidge in terms of value. Gagne is the only closer I would rather have than Lidge.

[WiseAndEck]

I'll take K-Rod any day of the week. Did I mention I am an Angels fan?

brian

[CrimeDog]

Have you heard anything about K-Rod being overused in the winter leagues?? Is it something to worry about?