Here they come. Time breakdown, just to underscore the value of the template:
Debugging (spelling, standardizing first and last names, syntax and spacing, etc) = 3 hrs
Sorting and arranging data = 20 minutes
Making tables = 20 minutes
I went ahead and ran max and min scores for each player, as well as calculating how many "ballots" each appeared on.
Some interesting results of note:
The most unsual player was Jose Guillen, who appeared on all 20 ballots, but with a mean score of only 15.
23 players appeared on all 20 ballots (clearly showing a lot of consensus).
12 different players appeared on only 1 ballot.