Yoda wrote:The Jury wrote:Maybe, but I'm really fond of the stud sluggers...
A guy like Maggs really floats my boat with his .310+ BA and his MONSTER RBI numbers. And my league always uses hits, so he's a beast of an OF.
What is really interesting is that Matsui put up numbers in 04 that Ordonez put up before his injury. Yet you still prefer Maggs who has some serious question mark regarding his health as well as where he will end up playing. If he ends up some place like DET, even IF he stays healthy, he will produce like Matsui. And his health is a BIG if.
I knew this would come up. Projections are projections to me. So until he actually takes that step back (be it due to Comerica or other factors) then he's a bigtime slugger in my books. Roto vs. H2H also has a huge role in this decision. In H2H leagues, I love the big potential guys, whereas in Roto, you need the consistent production all year long, so injuries are a huge concern.