Hideki Matsui or Maggs Ordonez???

[Purple Haze]

Matsui or Ordonez?

Who will have the better year?

And what do you project there stats to be?

Thanks

[so0perspam]

I'll go Matsui ... again, less injury risk and 30+ HR, 100+ runs, and 100+ RBI isn't too shabby either.

[Pedantic]

I'll go Matsui ... again, less injury risk and 30+ HR, 100+ runs, and 100+ RBI isn't too shabby either.

I agree. I love Maggs' upside, but Matsui gets the nod on being a far safer pick.

[The Jury]

I gotta go with Maggs for the upside. Picking Matsui is just another generic OF at 30-100-100..

[so0perspam]

I gotta go with Maggs for the upside. Picking Matsui is just another generic OF at 30-100-100..

And since when is that a bad thing ....

[gtech4life]

I'll go Matsui ... again, less injury risk and 30+ HR, 100+ runs, and 100+ RBI isn't too shabby either.

i agree
and hes a lock for 30/100/100 and will most likely do better than that
matsui-no risk
ordonez is an injury risk

[bleach168]

The last year Maggs was healthy, he failed to hit 30 homeruns AND failed to get 100 RBIs.

I'm not sure Maggs' upside is that much higher than Matsui. It's not worth the risk imo.

[DK]

I'd go with Matsui here.

[Pedantic]

I gotta go with Maggs for the upside. Picking Matsui is just another generic OF at 30-100-100..

.300-30-100 isn't something you pick up at the grocery store on the way home. And as far as upside goes, how much better than that could Ordonez's numbers be if he's completely healthy and hits like the pre-'03 Ordonez?

[jeff926]

matsui for sure with this one.