Furcal or Renteria

[SaintsOfTheDiamond]

Renteria won't hit two in BOS, I can almost guarantee that. He doesn't get on consistently enough to bat that high, at least he never did in STL. I think batting in the 6 spot in that lineup last year was actually a much better position than the two hole fantasy wise. Renteria will never hit for much power, so almost always having Pujols, Edmonds, and/or Rolen on in front of him to drive in with base hits -- his strength -- and occasional HR was more valuable than being knocked in by them to get the runs.

[Pogotheostrich]

Renteria didn't hit 2nd in STL consistantly cause he said he feels more comfortable further down in the order. My guess is he hits 6 or 7 in Boston. Everything I have seen shows Bellhorn hitting 2nd.

I would go with Renteria cause I think he has a better upside than Furcal. Although, chances are like many have said that Furcal could be a better value based on his draft spot.

[free]

furcal because this is a fantasy