Pedro or Schilling?

[Purple Haze]

Which one would you want in a keeper league, and which one will have the best season?

Thanks

[Dans]

I think it's too early to tell with Schilling as far as this season goes. He could be ready opening day, or miss a few starts. I'd probably rather have Curt in a keeper league but I think Pedro will have an excellent year in 2005.

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd take Pedro.

[thomasps3]

Pedro in a redraft
Schilling in a keeper

[Melo255]

I'd rather have Schilling in either setting

[shortsavage]

I'd rather have Schilling in either setting

Ditto. Pedro's injuries and difficulities have kept him from being the steady Cy-Young contender that Schilling has transformed into. Besides, can anyone really afford to have a Met anchor their pitching staff ?

[kage812004]

schilling all day!!

i know this has nothing to do with this but what he did in the playoffs this past season was unreal, i will never EVER forget.

[Pacman]

I think Shilling's the slightly better fantasy pick, both are verrrry good options.

I wont' be at ALL surprised to see Pedro have a HUGE season for the Mets this year.

[NZF]

I'm expecting Pedro to have a big year in New York and put up better numbers than Schilling.

In a Keeper league I'd still say Pedro, just.

[red]

I'd rather have Schilling in either setting

Ditto. Pedro's injuries and difficulities have kept him from being the steady Cy-Young contender that Schilling has transformed into. Besides, can anyone really afford to have a Met anchor their pitching staff ?

Geez, Savage, I hope you're in one of my leagues-- heck all of my leagues! If you want to avoid Mets this year (Pedro) maybe the pitcher in the national league, (Beltran) maybe the best overall player in the national league-- go ahead. I'll take those two while you avoid Mets on principle...