Miguel Cabrera or Marcus Giles?

[Sunspot]

I see your point, it sucks to have to dock someone for trying extra hard. Maybe trying extra hard will get him a couple more Stolen Bases or help him stretch a few singles into doubles or doubles into triples. Now if there was only extra fantasy points for "Web Gems"

[The Jury]

I'd have to go with Cabrera. He appears to have more potential and Giles already has an injury history this early in his career.

I think anyone who collides at full speed with another player has an "injury history", but this particular injury doesn't make a player "Injury Prone." might as well throw the injury concern out the window when you are evaluating Giles.

High impact injuries have a higher potential to come into effect later on, while Cabrera is in mint condition

[irishdude103]

M Cab

[so0perspam]

Cabrera by a wide, wide, wide margin.

Cabrera is on the elite level when it comes to keepers.

Most definitely, M-Cab and it's not even close.

[bucsfan04]

No question about it, Cabrera.

[Lofunzo]

You're kidding right?

Cabrera.

My thoughts exactly.

[CrimeDog]

I'm a huge Marcus Giles fan but I'd still take Cabrera

[CubsFan7724]

Cabrera, and its not even close. When we are talking like a top 3 round pick, position scarcity doesn't matter as much.

[TB13]

Unless you are in a league which counts home runs from 2nd basemen as 2 homeruns, M Cab by a wide, wide margin.

[Yoda]

Rough call. I would consider Giles because of the low depth at 2b. OF like Cabera are a dime a dozen and he is going to go for a premium because of his age and hype

I disagree that OF like Cabrera are dime a dozen. He is a special player who is going to be awesome for a long time.

Giles is a good player but he doesn't ride the same bus even though he has many more years of service.