I won season last year, then tanked in playoffs...rate pleas

[WV Pirate]

C-Mauer and Pudge
1B-Helton
2B-Reyes and Upton
3B-Blalock
SS-To move Reyes there, Jose Valentine till then
OF-Manny
OF-Dunn
OF-Posednik
DH-Thome
P-Sanatana
P-Pedro
P-Oliver Perez
P-Benson
P-Isringhausen
P-Webb
P-newly aquired Brad Penny

Not much on the bench, but prospects and Steve Finley

HTH, 5X5 Points based league

[Shadowmaster28]

The only thing I can see is that you may need help at 2B/SS but other than that you have a solid team that will compete year in and year out!

[kentx12]

Nice team but I am not sure that upton will be starting this year.

[CubsFan7724]

Wow your team is nuts. Those pitchers are pretty insane, though you could use another closer. I would probably trade one of your catchers (probably Mauer since he has a lot of value) for another OF, because Dunn and Pods will annihilate your average. Other than that, very nice.

[WV Pirate]

I've tried since lastspring to trade Pudge, but no one realizes his value. Mauer is a long time keper as far as I'm concerned, this league is starting its fifth year so I need Mauer for the next decade or so.
Thanks for the input to all of you that have responded...

[Lofunzo]

The only thing that I would do is trade Pudge for a closer.