Peavy Damon Rollins

[LBJackal]

Not even close...

Peavy
.
.
.
.
.
Rollins
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Damon

what!?!?!?

for a different perspective - lets look at what each would have earned you in a standard 5x5 roto league last yr:

Peavy - $25.69
Rollins - $27.79
Damon - $36.74

Give me Damon - even if he falls off, the other two have to put up BETTER numbers to beat Damon.

Peavy missed a lot of time, and Damon will fall back to earth in the offensive cats and his SB's will keep dropping like they did last year. Unless we're playing with 2004 stats this isn't close IMO.

[kentx12]

Not even close...

Peavy
.
.
.
.
.
Rollins
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Damon

what!?!?!?

for a different perspective - lets look at what each would have earned you in a standard 5x5 roto league last yr:

Peavy - $25.69
Rollins - $27.79
Damon - $36.74

Give me Damon - even if he falls off, the other two have to put up BETTER numbers to beat Damon.

I would take Peavy 1st but would easily put Damon over Rollins.

[Heimush]

As far as the Damon Rollins part of it. First of all, the Baseball forecaster is very high on Rollins. His trends are all on the upswing. He's young. His k/BB has gotten better every year. Damon on the other hand looks like he had a magical year, but prob a bump higher then can be expected. Add in the SS and I dont see how Damon will have a better year. (but I could be wrong )


(Truth - I asked this question bc I was trying to decide on keepers - 2 of the three with Damon at $25 and Peavy and Rollins at $15.)