Which combo will have better season numbers?

[Andy1234]

Currently i have Aurila at SS and just aquired Giambi who would be my UTIL guy because I have Helton.

I was thinking about tradeing for Nomar, and I think I could get Hunter from him too.

So, my question is who will have better 5X5 stats at the end of the year:

Giambi and Aurila

or

Nomar and Hunter

Position doesn't matter because 1 will be at SS and the other UTIL.

[Guest]

I think Giambi will have about 45 HR with 120 RBI, Aurila 15-80, Nomar 25-110, Hunter 25-90, so you lose out on HR and maybe a little on RBI but you gain in Hunters SB, depends on what you need more HR or SB.

[Andy1234]

I have Castillo, Abreu and Beltran for steals, so I am leaning toward keeping Giambi and Aurila and maybe trying to trade for a SS without giving up Giambi. Any thoughts on this, and do you think the 3 guys will give me enough SB in a 12 team league?