Rate My Dynasty Team

[Chilltownsdiddy]

League info: 18teams, 27 players each. Standard category league. Heres my team so far (Round 10 of 27)
C-R. Hernandez (11th round)
1B- J. Bagwell (7th Round)
2B- J. Vidro (10th Round )
SS- M. Young (3rd Round)
3B- M. Lowell (5th Round)
INF-
LF- M. Ramirez (1st ROund)
CF-A. Jones (6th ROund)
RF- T. Nixon (13th round)
Util-

SP-Peavy (2nd Round)
SP-Pavano (4th Round)
SP-B. Webb(6th ROund)
SP-J. Pineiro (8th Round)

CL-Jason Isringhausen (9th Round)
CL-G.Mota (12th Round)

ANy criticisms are welcomed!

[OhMrScottyTrav06]

LoL, You're in my league... Pennant Chasers

Oh and the categories are Hits, Runs, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OPS and Wins, Saves, K's, Holds, ERA, WHIP, K/BB

Here's my team:

C - J. Varitek (8th Round)
1B -
2B - B. Roberts (10th Round)
3B - A. Ramirez (3rd Round)
SS -
IF - M. Mora (5th Round)
LF - S. Podsednik (6th Round)
CF - V. Wells (4th Round)
RF - E. Byrnes (11th Round)
UT

SP - J. Santana (1st Round)
SP - J. Schmidt (2nd Round)
SP -
RP - B. Wagner (7th Round)
RP - K. Foulke (9th Round)
RP -
P -
P -
P -

Who's team is better so far?

***Edited with rounds drafted in (Please note there are 18 teams.

[Cornbread Maxwell]

It would help if you noted in what rd each player was taken.


It appears as though OhMrScotty has a great foundation so far.

If either of you can give a link to your draft we'd be able to discect it.

[chichpsalm]

I'm not high on Podsednik's chances this year as the Sox have publicly committed to playing small ball (read: sac bunts). Otherwise I say Scotty has the edge because of his pitching.

[Rico The Retard]

scotty has a little better team IMO

[Chilltownsdiddy]

I dont understand where you guys see that he has a better team than mine. Just dont see it at all. Me and Scotty will be updating this draft. And it would be much appreciated to see your guys opinions. Please more of them lol.

[ghostfacek]

oh damn.. im in this league too.... can you guys include me in the conversation?

(also, its H2H)

C - J. Kendall (7th Round)
1B - D. Lee (5th Round)
2B - A. Soriano (1st Round)
3B -
SS - K. Matsui (6th Round)
IF - S. Green (8th Round)
LF - G. Jenkins (10th Round)
CF - M. Kotsay (14th Round)
RF - Ichiro S. (2nd Round)
UT - J. Giambi (13th Round)

SP - R. Johnson (3rd Round)
SP - M. Mussina (4th Round)
SP - J. Smoltz (9th Round)
SP - G. Maddux (11th Round)
SP - B. Lawrence (12th Round)
SP - D. Lowe (15th Round)
RP - A. Otsuka (16th Round)
RP -
RP -
P - J. Capellan (17th Round)
P -
P -

[Cornbread Maxwell]

chill:
Peavy in the 2nd is terrible pick - you overpaid for him.
pavano in the 4th - same thing - he was drafted way way too early.
Lowell in the 5th was way too early also.
AJones in the 6th I dont like either. Hrs are cheap, and thats basically all he brings. His BA actually hurts you.
Overall, I think you had a very difficult time weighing value and drafting players for cost.

Scotty:
1st of all - Mora in the 5th could be the steal of the draft - nothing like getting a top 10 player from last yr in the 5th rd.
Varitek in the 8th is good value.
You may have overpaid slightly for Wells, but we'll see.
Wagner in the 7th - Foulke in the 9th!?!?!? two more candidates for steals of the draft. Im shocked Foulke lasted until the 9th rd - thats insane.

Ghost:
Sori, Ichiro as top 2 picks were solid.
RJ in the 3rd??? um, nice pick I guess. Many people will tell you he's probably the best fantasy pitcher this yr, so consider 3rd rd a steal of the draft type pick. If he pitches the way he did last yr in NY he will be a top 5 overall fantasy player.
Lee in the 5th is a good pick
KMatsui in the 6th was too early. I really like him this yr, but I think he will go around the 10th rd or later in many drafts.
Kendall int he 7th is great value.
You could have done better than Jenkins in the 10th
Smoltz was good value in the 9th.

[raiders_umpire]

chill:
Peavy in the 2nd is terrible pick - you overpaid for him.
pavano in the 4th - same thing - he was drafted way way too early.
Lowell in the 5th was way too early also.
AJones in the 6th I dont like either. Hrs are cheap, and thats basically all he brings. His BA actually hurts you.
Overall, I think you had a very difficult time weighing value and drafting players for cost.

Scotty:
1st of all - Mora in the 5th could be the steal of the draft - nothing like getting a top 10 player from last yr in the 5th rd.
Varitek in the 8th is good value.
You may have overpaid slightly for Wells, but we'll see.
Wagner in the 7th - Foulke in the 9th!?!?!? two more candidates for steals of the draft. Im shocked Foulke lasted until the 9th rd - thats insane.

Ghost:
Sori, Ichiro as top 2 picks were solid.
RJ in the 3rd??? um, nice pick I guess. Many people will tell you he's probably the best fantasy pitcher this yr, so consider 3rd rd a steal of the draft type pick. If he pitches the way he did last yr in NY he will be a top 5 overall fantasy player.
Lee in the 5th is a good pick
KMatsui in the 6th was too early. I really like him this yr, but I think he will go around the 10th rd or later in many drafts.
Kendall int he 7th is great value.
You could have done better than Jenkins in the 10th
Smoltz was good value in the 9th.

very well put...i just cant see how rj lasted til round 3......and mora was a great pick as well......

[Chilltownsdiddy]

Thanks Cornbread Maxwell for the harsh criticism of my team lol.