3 Injured Pitcher: Prior, Hudson, Or Halladay?

[GreenMonsterGoon]

I actually have Hudson ahead of the other two. Is there a single person who agrees with me?

[so0perspam]

No, it definitely goes:

Prior

Hudson


Halladay

[kentx12]

No, it definitely goes:

Prior

Hudson


Halladay

Yea that is how it should be.

[Mustangs989]

I have it...
Prior
Hudson
Halladay

[raiders_umpire]

No, it definitely goes:

Prior

Hudson


Halladay

that is my way as well....and i absolutley love hudson but he cant match up with prior.....

[Mugwump]

I'll throw in my .02 with Prior, Hudson, Halladay.

[SaintsOfTheDiamond]

No, it definitely goes:

Prior

Hudson


Halladay

that is my way as well....and i absolutley love hudson but he cant match up with prior.....

Same here. I'm expecting a Cy Young caliber year from Hudson in ATL, but Prior could easily beat him out if healthy.

[GreenMonsterGoon]

Here's the rationale:

1. Hudson plays for a better team and is more likely to get more wins.

2. Hudson has significantly less injury risk

3. 2004 Statistics

Hudson: 188 ip, 12wins, 103k's, 3.53 era, 1.26whip

Prior: 118 ip, 6 wins, 139 k's, 4.02 era, 1.35whip

Hudson better in 4/5 categories

[so0perspam]

Here's the rationale:

1. Hudson plays for a better team and is more likely to get more wins.

2. Hudson has significantly less injury risk

3. 2004 Statistics

Hudson: 188 ip, 12wins, 103k's, 3.53 era, 1.26whip

Prior: 118 ip, 6 wins, 139 k's, 4.02 era, 1.35whip

Hudson better in 4/5 categories

2004 Games Started:

Prior- 21
Hudson- 26

[perlick29]

If Halladay is fully recovered, then I have it Prior-Halladay-Hudson.

I just love Halladay as a dominating pitcher, I think he's better than Hudson.

BUT- I dont think he's fully recovered.

so,

Prior
Hudson
Halladay