SP rankings

[TheYanks04]

How would youru rank the following SPs in 5x5 (assume 12 teams)?

Orlando Hernandez
D. Wells
Clemens
Radke
Maddux
Westbrook
Livan Hernandez
Lieber
Morris
Woody Williams
Pettitte
Colon

[XTSilver]

Clemens - assuming he plays of course
Radke
Colon
Maddux
Lieber
Livan
Woody
Westbrook
Morris
Pettitte
Wells
El Duque

[Cornbread Maxwell]

Clemens - easily the best of the group if he plays.

Colon - had a terrible start, but came back very strong in the 2nd half

Maddux - solid solid solid

Lieber - He looked pretty good last yr after missing 2003, and has been nothing but solid before that, so I gotta like him.

MMorris - look for a solid yr from him - his ERA was inflated last yr

Radke - coming off a career yr - He'll be overpriced. Dont expect an ERA much under 4.

WWilliams - His ERA will drop back below .4 and he should have a good yr

Westbrook - streaky but very interesting - he could be the real sleeper/value pick in this group.

Dookie - Im too scared to trust he is only 35 and the change in scenery is a big ? too.

Wells - good wins, avg %s, be careful of his health.

Pettitte - one of the most overrated fantasy SPs around - avoid

disaclaimer: these rankings are subject to change on a whim - many are just too close to make that much of a difference.

[rlee]

Clemens - the oldest and still the best; IF he comes back

Maddux - not the elite pitcher he was, but still a good #3 fantasy pitcher

Pettitte - motivated to justify his contract

Colon - his physical condition is of great concern; you never know which Bartolo you're getting on a given day

Lieber - steady in his comeback last year; the ballpark in Philly scares me, even though he's a grounball pitcher

Radke - his control always helps his WHIP

D. Wells - has historically done poorly at Fenway???

W. Williams - could be a huge sleeper this year pitching at PETCO

Westbrook - did well last year with few K's. Can he repeat?

El Duque - how old is he really? What effect will the Sox park have on him?

Morris - starts the year coming off of surgery. I think he's done. He's lost velocity, the trademark curve has lost its bite.

[Pogotheostrich]

Clemens
Colon
Maddux
Radke
Livan Hernandez
D. Wells
Morris
Lieber
Westbrook
Pettitte
Woody Williams
Orlando Hernandez

[GreenMonsterGoon]

Clemens
Westbrook
Colon
Radke
D. Wells
Maddux
Livan Hernandez
Morris
Lieber
Pettitte
Woody Williams
Orlando Hernandez

[Rico The Retard]

Clemens
Radke
Colon
Morris- i like him for this year
Maddux
L. Hernandez
Petitite
Westbrook
Wells
Lieber
El Duque
Woody

[The Thrill]

How would youru rank the following SPs in 5x5 (assume 12 teams)?

Orlando Hernandez 12
D. Wells 10
Clemens 1
Radke 2
Maddux 3
Westbrook 6
Livan Hernandez 4
Lieber 9
Morris 11
Woody Williams 7
Pettitte 8
Colon 5