Sheets would most likely be gone by the 3rd round in a 12-team league. I have him as the most promising of the young lions at SP, ahead of Perez, Zambrano, Peavy, and Beckett. His numbers were filthy last year. His run support is awful, though, so I don't see him getting more than 12 or 13 wins. Last year, with a 2.7 ERA he only got 12 wins.
He's also pitched a ton of innings over the last three years for such a young pitcher. That's a testament to his durability, but he should be careful less he run the risk of throwing his arm out, like a number of other young studs have done over the past few years.
I am the Master. Don't question the Master. Just do what he says and be proud.