No way I would ever choose Dye over Nixon. Dye is a player who still gets drafted on his potential, and I would never draft him, even with a gun to my head. Nixon will never get 110 RBI, as he hits like 6th or 7th in Boston, but you can pencil him in for 25 HR,90 RBI with a .290 BA. Dye has the body of a 79 year old geriatric man who needs a Lark to get around. Avoid him at all costs!